Have you ever encountered a real estate listing that looks nothing like the property? Experts say the use of artificial intelligence in the industry is becoming more common, as agents increasingly turn to technology to “virtually stage” homes. But at the same time, the practice has given rise to concerns that AI could be used to make more fundamental changes to a property, like expanding the dimension of a room for example.
In October, the regulatory body for Ontario’s real estate industry rolled out updated guidelines on the use of artificial intelligence in the industry, so prospective buyers don’t have to play detective on whether a listing’s image has been altered or not. Among other things, Real Estate Council of Ontario (RECO) expects industry professionals to independently review all AI-generated content before publishing property details and to disclose when AI is being used to stage or alter photos.
RECO is also prohibiting agents from entering confidential client information into public AI platforms. RECO says it developed its AI guidelines to help navigate potential risks and to protect consumers, so that they can rely on accurate property listings. “If agents decide to use AI in real estate marketing, RECO’s expectations are that they verify the accuracy of AI-generated content against physical facts and can be transparent about the use of AI or materially altered content in their advertising and/or property listings,” Tess Lin, director of communications for RECO, wrote in an email to CTV News Toronto.
All visuals that are generated by AI must
All visuals that are generated by AI must adhere to the advertising obligations outlined in the provincial Trust in Real Estate Services Act. The act clearly states that any industry professional found to be using deceptive, false or misleading advertising material needs to take it down and issue either a correction or retraction. Marco Pedri, a real estate broker with Shoreline Realty, underscored how big a role marketing plays in the industry, since their primary goal is to match the right buyers to the right properties to make their sales.
“Just because you have an appealing listing, if it doesn’t match what they’re going to see in person, at the end of the day, they’re not going to act on it,” Pedri said. “So, just because you have eyes on it virtually or online, doesn’t necessarily mean it’s going to convert to a sale or a lease.” While AI can be helpful and is used to streamline administrative work, one realtor says it is up to the agent to use it responsibly and ensure there’s no misrepresentation or misleading information provided to prospective buyers.
Amrit Walia, a realtor with Royal Le Page Signature in Toronto, says his brokerage has been using AI for virtual staging for some time. “We’ve been using it for virtual staging, and sometimes, it leads to misleading information too. At times I’ve seen, but not all the time,” Walia said. Walia said AI can be used to illustrate how rooms can be used to help consumers visualize a property’s potential but it should never alter structural features of a home.
AI can make a property look better,
“AI can make a property look better, but it should not make the property look different,” he said. “If you change the permanent property features, that’s a red flag in my opinion, but it helps in enhancing the listing or helps the consumer to understand … the potential of the property.” Shion Guha, an assistant professor in the faculty of information at the University of Toronto and director of the Human-Centered Data Science Lab, agreed that there’s a line between staging and misrepresentation.
Using AI to move furniture around is fine, he says, while using it to change the dimensions of the home is not. “There’s so many kind of listings that are like ‘This is a great investment opportunity, you can do X, Y, Z, and here’s how this room would look like if there was a partition in the middle,’” Guha said. “That kind of stuff, I think, is quite problematic.” Walia says from what he has seen, most agents have used AI responsibly so far.
The Toronto Regional Real Estate Board (TRREB) said its professional standards department addresses all AI-altered photographs that do not accurately depict real estate listings. “For instance, limited adjustments such as colour correction, brightness modification, contrast, enhancement, and virtual staging are permissible, provided such edits do not materially alter the factual accuracy of the image or misrepresent any feature, condition or view of or from the property,” TRREB’s CEO John DiMichele said in a statement to CTV News Toronto.
Any member found to have used an inaccurate
Any member found to have used an inaccurate photo will have a chance to rectify the issue, DiMichele says, but if they continue to use these pictures, they will escalate the matter to the professional standards tribunal. “At TRREB, we actively monitor listings and investigate complaints related to non-compliant images and take appropriate steps to address issues when they occur,” DiMichele said.
Lin says RECO has received “very few” complaints about the use of AI. Out of all the complaints the real estate regulator has received this year so far, about 2,500 complaints in total, RECO says about 12 per cent of them were about the misrepresentation of property information. Family says AI was used in AirBnb listing Though it wasn’t pertaining to a real estate listing exactly, CTV News Toronto previously reported on how a family felt duped by Airbnb after the accommodation they booked for their daughter didn’t line up with the pictures that were available online.
The photos that were used in that particular listing showed a room with warm lighting, several houseplants, a bed with hotel-quality linens, and a bathroom with an illuminated mirror and brass or golden fixtures. The pictures the family shared with CTV News Toronto revealed a different version of the room they thought they had booked, with the bathroom being the most obvious with its lack of warm-toned finishes.
With regards to real estate listings, Guha says realtors could disclose what parts of a listing’s photos have been altered with AI for transparency’s sake with prospective buyers. “Like, was this table put in there? Was this chair put in there? Is the whole thing AI-generated? I think that part is important for agents to consider,” Guha said. “Consumers, buyers, should not have to become a detective to figure out what exactly is going on right.”
